Friday, April 15, 2011

Avocados for Kuala Lumpur

After my blog about avocados in 2007, I have been getting requests for avocado plants that I have found difficult to respond to on a case-by-case basis. Yesterday I made a deal with a retail outlet at the 1 Utama Shopping Mall. This is a small place called Hortpark Nursery on the Lower Ground Floor, next to the Mamak Corner. I have placed two plants there, which are all that I have to spare at present. Hortpark Nursery will take care of them and sell at RM25 per plant to cover their expenses. Hortpark also sells horticarbon in 5 and 10 kg bags. Shoppers should bring bring their own strong bag for big items. Hortpark is open from 10am to about 6pm.

The avocado plants being made available are seedlings from the best plant of about 20 selected clones that I have tested. The clones were acquired by MARDI (Malaysian Agricultural Research and Development Centre) through international collaboration many years ago. The Research Assistant in charge of the collection offered me a duplicate set of this collection. I was at that time establishing the Fruit Tree Arboretum at FRIM (Forest Research Institute Malaysia). He brought me a set of bud-grafted plants all the way from MARDI to FRIM, a considerable distance to cover on his motorcycle, at his own expense. This person was about to retire and felt that his many years of effort would disappear without a trace unless he could pass it on. He was right! Avocados have disappeared from MARDI’s agenda.

I planted most of the clones at FRIM, and a few around my house. Over the next 20 years, some of the trees failed to flower and fruit under our conditions. One flowered but never fruited. One remained stunted at about 3 ft tall. One fruited only after 10 years. One produced oversized fruits, but only in small numbers. The collection in FRIM gradually died out after I retired, but I had already identified and propagated the best tree.

This tree fruited at 6 years old and has been fruiting every year. The fruits are smooth-skinned, green in colour, and medium sized (supermarket size), with smooth pulp. It is self-fertile, which means a single tree is enough to produce fruits. This is the tree that I have been propagating and giving away, but I can only produce a small number at a time.

At about the same time as the avocados were offered to me, another scientist, working at an oil palm research centre, Bakasawit, was about to retire to England. He offered me an international collection of coconut varieties that he feared would be lost upon his retirement. Sadly, I had no place for coconuts in FRIM.

Those were times when scientists collaborated across institutions and did what they thought was best in the public interest. That spirit no longer exists.

There are extensive ‘germplasm’ collections of rubber, oil palm, bananas, sweet potatoes, etc in our research institutes, many acquired through exploration and exchange at great cost and effort. All are in danger of being lost upon the retirement of the scientists who built them up, but it is almost impossible for outsiders to get anything out. They are treated like official secrets.

I am working with UTAR at its university campus in Kampar to set up an agricultural resource centre where we hope to establish our own collections for research, teaching, propagation, distribution and exchange. Avocados will be on the agenda, with other fruits and plants of agri-horticultural interest. We hope to establish an ethical model of trust and collaboration between scientists and the public, without which Malaysian agriculture will stagnate.

69 comments:

  1. Dr Ng,

    I have an Avocado plant about 3 years old, grown from seed. The seed was from a fruit tree grown by a neighbor. This tree produces lots of fruits yearly, in fact baby plants sprouted easily from the fallen fruits. From your experience, what is the chance that my avocado plant will never fruit or even flower but won't bear fruit?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi there! I know I am being a little bit shameless right now but is your tree growing well? Do you think I minght have a chance of getting my hands on the seed? Thank you!

      Delete
    2. Dr.Ng,
      I am Ricko Chong, a Msian living in Aruothai, Chiang Mai, Thailand. Here we are beginning to grow more avocado trees.The ppl here have learned their lessons after finding that most of their trees do not bear fruits after so many years but they then grafted good scions onto the stumps.
      Now there is a big demand for grafted avocado seedlings from a few countries around here.
      We have 8 varieties of good avocados. A good variety must be very prolific fruiting, The seed must be small n the skin smooth n clean. Avocado trees are rough n tough and fast growing. They can grow well in both hot or fairly cool weather and they can tolerated wet weather. The fruits may drop prematurely if water stressed.
      I strongly feel our Msian weather is very suitable and the skin of the fruits is very hard n long shelf life of at least a few weeks. The fruits are harvested when they are big n still green n keep outdoor a week or more for them to be soften then they can be eaten.
      I suggest Utar import some seedlings to sell to the people here who are interested. I can delivered to Msia in pickup up to 250 seedling or 6 wheeler lorry up to 2000 seedlings.
      I hv 8 varieties n ready stock. I can be contacted by WA 60162297168 or by my email or Ricko Chong in fb.

      Delete
  2. Your tree has a good chance of being like its parent since it is being grown in the same climate and environment.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for Dr Ng for the prompt feedback. What a relief !

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello Dr Ng

    After a long search and anticipation, through a friend, I managed to get one of the avocado plant from Hort Park 1u.

    I plan to plant it outside my house. However, would need your advise how to care for the plant - to ensure it is alive, healthy and eventually bear fruits in years to come!

    Please advise

    Lee

    ReplyDelete
  5. May Yee, let's keep in touch through this website. Your plant is big enough to transfer to the ground now. Select a sunny place and surround the plant with sticks or stones to protect it from the grass-cutters.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Oh I wish by this weekend when I get there I would still be able to get that last tree.....thanks anyway.

    ReplyDelete
  7. (off-topic)
    Dear Dr Ng,

    Sorry to post off-topic but I could not find your contact details on your profile.

    May I know if there is a way for me to purchase a hardbound autographed copy of your book online? I wish to give this as a gift to my husband.

    Thank you in advance.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Regarding the hardcover edition of my book, I will arrange for Hort Park at 1 U sell autographed copies. I will post a note on my next blog once this is confirmed.

    Regarding avocados, two more plants will be available at end of next month (end of May 2011).

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hello Dr Ng,

    Thank you for your reply. Thank you for the tip. Will stay in touch.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hi Dr Ng,
    I am planning to plant an avocado tree outside my house both for the fruits and for shade. I have a 2 feet tall plant grown from a South African avocado that I bought from Giant last year. However, I am worried that it will grow very huge. My mum's friend has two very old avocado trees outside her house in Kajang. The fruits have an unusual shape, ie shaped like long curved plump cucumbers. The trees are so huge that I can't even put my arms around the trunks. They are taller than a double story-link house. You mentioned about pruning it to maintain it at a height of 20 feet. Can you please upload a picture of your good avocado tree with close-ups of its fruits and leaves so that we avocado enthusiasts can view your tree online. How do we maintain the tree at the desired height without drastic pruning that will make the tree weak?

    Is it possible to plant different varieties of avocados in separate pots first and then wait a few years to see whether they flower and fruit first to check the fruit quality before I transfer the desired plant to the ground?

    Christina

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hi Christina
    I have never seen avocados fruiting when grown in large pots. To do the experiment, you should use a plant that you know for sure will fruit in KL. Then if it fails you can blame the pot. Otherwise you would never find out whether it is the tree or the pot that is to blame.

    I will take photos of my tree and post it in a new blog next week.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Oops, I meant you should use a plant that is known for sure to fruit in your area. I had assumed that you live in KL.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hi Dr Ng,
    I stumbled upon your site while looking for avocado plants. Im so pleased to discover that there are local varieties that can grow here! I was wondering if there are any more avocado plants at Hort Park or any more in the hear future? Went there yesterday afternoon to find out, but it was closed.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I am sorry the HortPark outlet is closed. There was not enough business to keep it open.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Oh, no wonder. Thanks for the info anyway.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hi Dr Ng,

    I'm interested to plant the avocado,
    is there anyway to purchase your seedling since you have mention earlier that the hortpark have close.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Dear dr ng,
    I'm planning to plant an avacado tree together wt with other fruit trees as part of my new house's organic edible landscape. I'm from penang, i wonder if there is a posdibility to get a seed from dr ng by post? I'll post you a small box wt my address attached wt postage needed. Thank you! My email: lee.weilian@gmail.com cheers!

    ReplyDelete
  18. DR. Ng
    I have an avocado tree that flowered this year for the first time. (3 years old) Small fruits appeared last week. This week they are gone. Not on the ground just gone.
    Any idea what has caused them to disappear.

    ReplyDelete
  19. In my experience nothing eats avocado fruits on the trees but the fruits can abort and fall off. The evidence should be on the ground unless somebody has deliberately picked them. 3 years is a record fast time for avocados to flower but if the trees are too small the fruits will abort.

    I get requests every month for seeds or plants but cannot supply. However I am establishing a collection of select fruit trees in the UTAR campus in Kampar and in about 6 years the farm manager should be able to provide plants to the public.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Dr. Ng,
    We planted these seedlings from a producing tree 3 years ago here in South Florida. Perfect growing conditions. The trees are over 20 feet tall. Lots of flowers a month ago and then small fruit. We have seen no evidence of falling fruit. Perhaps just not mature enough to sustain the growth.

    Thank you for your input.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Ding Siew Ming (datin)Tue Apr 24, 11:32:00 AM PDT

    Hai Dr Ng
    I stumble on your blog while googling for info on where to find a fruiting avocado tree to source for a shoot to be grafted to 2 seedlings I grew from seeds . The seeds were from fruits I bought in Brestagi near Medan. Ì was informed that plants from seeds wont fruit or if it does it will be a 10 yr wait. Ì rea
    d from yr other articles you have a fruiting plant in front of yr house. Çan you be kind enough to spare me some twigs? W here is your house in KL?
    Ì retired from the Department of agriculture 16 yrs ago

    ReplyDelete
  22. Dear Dr. Ng,

    I was so excited to see your blog, but what a let down to learn that Hort Park outlet is closed!

    I know you get deluged by email requests for seedlings, but I would love to buy one if it's available.

    We are big fans of avocado, and would be happy to act as your nursery/distributor. My father has extensive gardening experience (durian, mango, rambutan, ciku, starfruit, papaya, banana, pineapple) and is retired, so he has plenty of time to look after the plants!

    Please email me at EeCheng_Ong@brown.edu if you're interested. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So sorry cannot reach you by your email address. I can supply u avocado grafted seedlings. WA 60162297168 or email: rickodiscus@gmail.com

      Delete
  23. Hi. I'm curious to know. i bought an avocado tree (small size in plastic bag) from jabatan pertanian serdang last month. i plan to plant it behind of my kitchen as i'm living in semi-D house which have about 20x30 (ft) extra land. until today, i still do not transfer it to the ground as someone told me if the tree grow bigger, the root will damage the house. What do u think? is it true?

    ReplyDelete
  24. Huda, you can 'bonsai' any tree to any size you want by pruning the tree to fit the size of your space. An avocado left to grow freely will grow to 100 ft tall but for your house I suggest cutting the top off at 5 or 6 ft to promote low branching. After that you should regularly prune the shoots to keep the tree at about 15 ft tall. The root size is controlled by the crown size. You should start the pruning programme while the tree is young and adaptable.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Hi Dr. Ng,
    I'm really excited to find that I could plant Avocados in Malaysia but unfortunately Hort Park outlet is closed. Do you have other distributors? I would love to start planting my own avocados!

    My email is jasontan81@gmail.com please do let me know there are others that is providing the seedlings!! thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  26. I am sorry I have not been able to make any new arrangements for distributing avocados. The demand is too small and irregular at present.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Dear Dr Ng,

    You are the expert in this area, and I think you are the right person to ask rather than me asking the wikipedia.

    I am now in the initial stage of doing survey for feasibility of planting avocado in Malaysia. (Commercially) Do you think that the India Avocado fruit (big size) can grown commercially in Malaysia? The current supermarket avocado are a bit expensive and small size for normal class local people to be able to enjoy this delicious food. Please advice me:D

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, I am Ricko Chong from Msia now living in Arunothai Chiang Mai. I am very interested in avocados hopefully can grow commercially in Msia. Here we have a few varieties that are suitable for our warm n wet weather.
      Pinkerton, Peterson, both dwarf varieties, Buccaneer n Reed big size plant n fruits.
      A good commercial variety must be prolific fruiting,reasonable size,small seed, good taste n long shelf life. We hv one variety very big size fruit but not so free fruiting, called Booth 7 or from Myanmar.

      Delete
  28. Hello Dr.Ng

    I like to read your blog and it is very informative.I'm interested in biochar/horti carbon.Is it still available in 1u?Or can I get it elsewhere?Thanks.=)

    ReplyDelete
  29. Hello Mr. Ng

    Where can I buy grafted avocado trees for my garden in Langkawi and also KK ??

    Thanks Tim Russell
    timhrussell@live.com

    ReplyDelete
  30. Hello Dr Ng,

    I bought the avocado plant back in 2011 from Hort Park 1utama and planted it outside my house. Now it's about 3.5 to 4 feet tall with few branches and big leaves. It's nice and healthy (shame that I couldn't post a picture). My understanding is it would grow to a huge tree before it flowers/fruits. Right now, I just leave it as it is and water it occassionally. Let me know if I am on right track.

    ReplyDelete
  31. May Yee
    You can keep any tree small by pruning the top

    ReplyDelete
  32. Hi Dr Ng,

    I'm planning on planting avocado in my house, so excited to know there are others planting in Malaysia. Noted that this post was 2 years ago but do you currently have any seedlings for sale?

    ReplyDelete
  33. Sorry, I do not produce any avocado plants now due to pressure of other work.

    I have established a plot of avocados in the UTAR campus in Kampar in the hope that this will become the future centre for development of avocado and other fruit trees under UTAR's horticulture programme. But it will take a few more more years of work.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Dr Ng,

    Do you still sell Avocado tree? Would like to get a few trees to plant in my dad orchard. Thank you.

    Pah

    ReplyDelete
  35. I am sorry I do not produce avocado plants anymore.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Too bad, Dr. do you know where i can get Avocado plant? Thank you very much

    ReplyDelete
  37. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Hi everyone, If you are interested... we have regular discussions on avocado grafted plants:

    https://www.facebook.com/groups/avocadoloversmalaysia/

    ReplyDelete
  39. Appreciate very much if somebody can give the address n contact number of the nursery selling avocado n chestnut tree. I am staying in the village in bangi. Thank you. Pls email me at hamdan1955@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  40. Hi Dr Ng,

    I have planted an avocado tree from fruits bought in KK Sabah and it started to flower last year after 4 years. Last year was not successful but more fruits have set in this year, and I am looking forward to taste the first fruit. I would like to know the name of Sabah fruit, which has smooth skin and about twice the size of Hass sold at supermarket.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Hi Dr Ng,
    I have an avacado plant about 6 years old, grown from seed. The plant grows well and starts to grow flowers and fruits. I'm hoping it grows many fruits since there's are so many flowers, but instead of many fruits, it's only grows few fruits. I've tried to put fertilizer but it's still the same and the plant can't hold flowers till it grows fruits. Anything i can do on the plant?

    ReplyDelete
  42. Hort Park Nursery no longer in business in 1 Utama. Do you know where I can buy bud grafted avocado plants from proven stock.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Can anyone who has a fruiting avocado plant spare me some branch and/or root cuttings. Email me at ptsgi@hotmail.com. Much appreciated

    ReplyDelete
  44. Can anyone who has a fruiting avocado plant spare me some branch and/or root cuttings. Email me at ptsgi@hotmail.com. Much appreciated

    ReplyDelete
  45. Hi Dr Francis Ng. Even the world seed bank has the same problem as MARDI,FIRIM and you. Resources! What make you think that 20years from now UTAR will still have avocado on their agenda. Different people will have different interest and divert resources to other projects.
    The best hope to keep your avocado clones going is you help spread it to enthusiast and promote it to farmers. They will help the clone spread and prosper with their own resources. To illustrate this, big oil palm plantation maintain pure breeding stock of D and P that can trace the ancestry back to more than 50 years.
    If you are busy maybe you can engage a nursery or an enthusiast to help you propagate and distribute your clones.
    There is a demand for good avocado hybrid in Malaysia as more people learning to appreciate avocados. Once the hybrid is commercialized successfully like in Indonesia, Philippines and Sabah you can be assured that your
    clones will live a long long time.

    ReplyDelete
  46. Dear Dr Ng,
    I would like to have an avocado plant in my garden. Where can I get a grafted plant?

    My 30-year-old mangosteen plant has finally started fruiting. So 4-5 years for avocado to fruit is not a long time.

    Please help. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  47. Dear Dr. Ng

    I would like to explore the idea of an organic avocado plantation in Seremban for both fruit and avocado oil. Would appreciate it if you could give me some advice on soil type, and care required. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Dear Dr Ng

    My 5 or 6 year old avocado tree is from Indonesia, grown from seed, taller than my 2 story house. It is beginning to flower now but I see little seeds as big as hazel nut on the ground, no fruits on the tree. What are chances that I will harvest any fruits at all?

    ReplyDelete
  49. Hi Dr Ng

    I would like to get an avocado tree that fruits, for planting, in my home in Sentul. Where can I get a hold of a small tree.

    Shan Palanisamy
    shanpalanisamy@sympatico.ca
    +01160-3345-1074

    ReplyDelete
  50. Hi, Dr Ng,
    I planted some avacodo tree from seed some year ago but still ni fruiting.
    I understand it may not true to tyoe from seed but i have no choice.
    I now ground a few avocado seedling and ready to be grafted. Any chance to get some graft wood from you.
    Thank you in advance.
    Regards
    Vincent Neng

    ReplyDelete
  51. Hi, Dr Ng,
    I planted some avacodo tree from seed some year ago but still ni fruiting.
    I understand it may not true to tyoe from seed but i have no choice.
    I now ground a few avocado seedling and ready to be grafted. Any chance to get some graft wood from you.
    Thank you in advance.
    Regards
    Vincent Neng

    ReplyDelete
  52. Hello Dr ng I was wondering is avocado plants were still sold at 1 utama ? I would really like to have one. Thank you

    Regards
    Keeran

    ReplyDelete
  53. Hello Dr Ng! I am in Kota Kinabalu and would like to introduce your avocado trees here. Is there a way to buy one or two and learn to propagate them? You can reach me at maparham42@gmail. Thank you for keeping this species going here!

    ReplyDelete
  54. Hi Dr Ng,

    We have a 1+ foot tall avocado plant in a pot in our house which we planted from seed. Not quite sure of the avocado species but it was bought from supermarket and tasted very creamy and meaty. It is possible if you know where we can get it bud-grafted or get a bud-grafted one in exchange for this plant instead? as I read online the chances of getting fruits if planted from seed is quite small.

    Thanks in advance!

    ReplyDelete
  55. Dear Dr Ng,

    Do you still leave behind the avocado tree for sale at the nursery? I am interested to plant one.

    Thanks.

    Wilson

    ReplyDelete
  56. Dear Dr Ng,

    If it is available, please let me know where to get them.

    Thanks again.

    Wilson

    ReplyDelete
  57. Dear Dr,
    I was wondering can the avocado tree be airlayered/tut? Will it bear fruit much earlier?

    ReplyDelete
  58. Where in Kulalumpur , nursery or university can a small grafted avocado of a dwarf variety be bought. Please let me know. email is ss1717@yahoo.com
    Sitka

    ReplyDelete
  59. Dear Dr Ng,

    I recently started up a new venture to solve the avo-issues in Malaysia (you know it’s very hard to get good quality avocados in the market nowadays… more info at https://www.avocadian.com )

    And yes, it’s been a very tough journey to deal with avocados… Since you’re really well experienced with avocado, I wonder if you could shed some light on what I’m doing? Do you think I provide values to the people? How could I improve it?

    Thank you very much! =)

    ReplyDelete
  60. Hi Dr Ng, can I know where I can get avacado plants in kl /Selangor.

    ReplyDelete
  61. Dear Dr Francis,

    I'm interested to learn more about avocado planting with Malaysian soil and climate. What would the best method of communication to contact you ?

    Best,
    Dayana

    ReplyDelete
  62. Million things hidden in one seed amazing thing to learn , il be happy to this journey with enlightenments from from the universe

    ReplyDelete
  63. Hi Dr Ng. I am planning to plant some avocado trees in my garden. May I know where can I buy this fruit bearing trees in Malaysia?

    ReplyDelete
  64. Where can I get some good quality avocado scions? I hv some avocados trees 2to 4 feet, planted from seeds and I intend to graft them tqq🙏🙏

    ReplyDelete
  65. Dr. Ng,
    In preparation of my retirement, i have two acres of farm land in Tanjong Malim. Apart from durain, i would like to plant some avogado and Nangka Royale and other exotic fruits. Please advise if I can buy some FNA-v1 avogado and Nangka Royale seedlings from you.

    Regards
    Tee
    teekimtsew@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete